Please fill out the  following  form and e-mail it to   jiti@loyno.edu

----------------------------------------------------------------------
               JOURNAL OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IMPACT
                             REVIEW FORM

1. PAPER ID: 
2. TITLE OF PAPER: 

3. RECOMMENDATION (A to D): 
   A. Accept -  Paper is good, publishable as is or with minor changes
   B. Accept with changes  -  Publishable, requires some modifications
   C. Marginal - Paper is fair, requires major modifications
   D. Reject - Paper is poor or not within JITI's scope

4. JUSTIFICATION FOR RECOMMENDATION.  
   Please rate  the  significance, originality, technical quality, and  
   clarity  of  the paper  on a scale of  1 (low)  to  5 (high).  This
   portion of the review WILL be returned to the author(s).

   4a. SIGNIFICANCE (1 to 5):
   Briefly comment on the significance of the paper. Your comments may
   focus on the following questions:
   - How important is the reported work?
   - Does it reveal the impact of IT on particular domain?
   - Are the presented effects of IT important/interesting/promising?
   Please enter your comments here:
   |
   |
   |
   |

   4b. ORIGINALITY (1 to 5):
   Briefly comment on the originality of the paper. Your comments may
   focus on the following questions:
   - Is this a new problem/approach/point of view?
   - Is this an innovative combination of existing/known techniques?
   - Has this work (or similar work) been previously reported?
   - Does the paper include sufficient/appropriate references?
   Please enter your comments here:
   |
   |
   |
   |

   4c. TECHNICAL QUALITY (1 to 5):
   Briefly comment on the technical quality of the paper. Your comments
   may focus on the following questions:
   - How accurate/reproducible are the results reported in this paper?
   - How much effort has apparently been invested in this research?
   - Is there theoretical/experimental support of the presented claims?
   - Are there any errors in the presented theoretical results/proofs?
   Please enter your comments here:
   |
   |
   |
   |

   4d. CLARITY (1 to 5):
   Briefly comment on the clarity of the paper below. Your comments may
   focus on the following questions:
   - Is the paper well-organized and well-written?
   - Will the paper be understandable by the general JITI audience?
   - Does the presentation allow a substantive evaluation of the work?
   - Are the references in APA style?
   Please enter your comments here:
   |
   |
   |
   |

   4e. ADDITIONAL COMMENTS TO AUTHOR(S).
   Please enter your comments here:
   |
   |
   |
   |

-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: The information below this line will NOT be sent to the author(s)

5. COMMENTS TO THE EDITORIAL BOARD:
   |
   |
   |

6. REVIEWER'S NAME:

7. REVIEWER'S EMAIL:

8. REVIEWER'S TELEPHONE NUMBER: (   ) ___ - _____